VoteMarinaCA.org
Follow the evidence. Verify the source.

Provide comments, corrections or updates

Help improve the accuracy and completeness of VoteMarinaCA.org.

Quick mobile view: This page starts with the main facts and keeps the source links available. Detailed models and wider research tables are easier to examine on a larger screen.

City Projects, Basic FAQs and Community Feedback

Another question: What other ways could Marina pay for the facilities? See funding alternatives and tradeoffs, including grants, impact fees, economic growth, phasing and borrowing.

Marina has many legitimate policy, budget and project questions. They do not all answer the Measure Q question. This page separates issues that directly affect the proposed Utility Users Tax from issues that are relevant to City oversight but use a different funding source, legal process or project decision.

Use this test: Is the issue actually funded by Measure Q or the General Fund? If not, does it still materially affect the City's overall financial capacity or the assumptions behind Measure Q? The answer can be direct, indirect, or separate.

Basic FAQs

Short answers to common questions about Measure Q, City funds, and the relationship between City issues and the proposed tax.

Does Marina have more than $200 million available, so Measure Q is not needed?

No. The money does not exist the way that claim makes it sound. Marina's latest audited report shows $213.37 million in cash and investments, but that is the total of many different City funds added together. Much of the money is restricted by law, held for a specific program, already set aside to projects, held for other agencies, or needed for City operations and reserves.

Simple answer: Marina has $213.37 million across all of these accounts. It does not have $213.37 million sitting unused and available for the new Police, Fire and City Hall facilities. Some City money can be used for those facilities. Much of the $213.37 million cannot simply be moved to them.

Where does the $213.37 million go?

Data table 1
Major groupAmountWhat it means
City government funds$177.62MGeneral government money spread among the General Fund, building and improvement projects, impact fees, FORA funds and other City funds. Much of it is restricted or already set aside.
City business-type funds$22.12MMoney tied to City business operations. It is not simply General Fund cash available for the three buildings.
Money held for others funds$13.63MMoney the City holds in trust or for specific obligations. It is not general City money available for the facilities.
Total cash and investments$213.37MThis is the number behind the $200 million claim.

Bottom line: The $213.37 million number is real. Saying all $213.37 million is available to build the three facilities is not. The useful question is how much of the City's existing money can legally and practically be used for those projects after restrictions, existing commitments, operations and reserves are taken into account.

Want the detailed breakdown? See where the money is restricted or set aside.

The City's audited governmental fund statements provide another view of the money. This is a fund-balance breakdown, not another $213.37 million to add to the table above.

Data table 2
Governmental fundFund balanceWhat it is for
General Fund$52.42MCity's main day-to-day fund. Only part of this balance is unassigned.
City Building and Improvement Projects$45.62MEarmarked for approved or carried-forward building and improvement projects.
Impact Fees$23.62MRestricted to improvements allowed by development-impact-fee rules.
FORA Dissolution$23.23MRestricted to allowed former Fort Ord/FORA purposes.
Abrams B debt service$0.55MHeld for debt payments.
Other governmental funds$25.98MMultiple smaller funds with their own purposes and restrictions.
Total governmental fund balance$171.42MThis is a different accounting measure from the $177.62M governmental cash-and-investment figure above.

Within governmental fund balances, about $29.8 million was classified as unassigned at June 30, 2025. Unassigned does not mean the City should spend all of it. It means it was not reported as restricted, set aside or assigned for another purpose at year-end. The City can also change some commitments through formal Council action, while restricted by law money has tighter limits.

See the audited City report and source details →

Quick relevance guide

Data table 3
IssueWhat it isMeasure Q connectionMore detail
Police, Fire and City HallReplacement or modernization of core City facilitiesDirect. These facilities are central to the stated Measure Q rationale.History · Debt · CFCAC
General City servicesPublic safety, streets, facilities and other General Fund servicesDirect. Measure Q is a general tax and is not legally limited to the three buildings.Measure Q · Funds
Aquatic & Recreation CenterSeparate building or improvement project and day-to-day programIndirect. Operations can affect the General Fund, but this is not the same building or improvement project.Budget
Preston ParkCity-owned rental housing and related project questionsIndirect. Its finances can matter, but balances are not automatically interchangeable with UUT money raised.Funds
Sea Haven / Dunes parksDevelopment-related parks and project obligationsMostly separate. Developer obligations, impact fees and grants have their own restrictions.Development
Equestrian CenterCity property and concession managementSeparate unless a material General Fund effect is documented.Budget
Cal Am litigationWater policy and litigation expenseIndirect. Spending is a budget question, but it is not itself the building funding proposal.Budget
Regional road projects, including Imjin ParkwayRoad, signal, landscaping and roundabout projectsMixed. Existing projects may use restricted transportation funds, while Measure Q also permits street and general-service spending.Imjin project review · Funds
Development incentivesNegotiated agreements intended to produce development and future money raisedIndirect. Each agreement should be tested for actual General Fund cost or foregone money raised.Development

Are Measure Q facts being presented differently by the City, campaign websites and social media?

Yes. The City of Marina and opponents of Measure Q often begin with some of the same actual facts but emphasize different parts. City communications generally emphasize facility needs, public safety, local funding and accountability. NoMarinaUUT.com emphasizes the legal flexibility of a general tax, the 7% rate, the lack of an automatic sunset and other City financial decisions.

Some statements from both perspectives are supported by the record. Others are interpretations, and some omit context that can materially change how a statement is understood.

The primary record is the benchmark. VoteMarinaCA compares both presentations with the ballot language, law, City financial analysis, CFCAC record, budgets and other original documents rather than treating either website as the neutral source.

Compare City and opposition claims side by side →

City Projects

Project records, funding sources, and the connection, if any, to Measure Q.

Police and Fire facilities

Are facility conditions relevant to Measure Q?

Yes. The official ballot question identifies firefighters, EMTs, police, emergency operations and repair or upgrade of police, fire and City buildings. The City currently estimates the core replacement facilities at approximately $69.3 million.

Does Measure Q legally guarantee every dollar goes to the buildings?

No. It is a general tax. The ballot language also includes streets, potholes and general City services. That legal distinction should remain visible even when the facilities are the principal policy rationale.

Measure Q structure → · Financing models →

Aquatic & Recreation Center

Do opening date, membership fees and day-to-day costs matter?

Yes, to the overall budget. The adopted FY 2025-26/FY 2026-27 budget calls for day-to-day policies, a membership campaign, staffing and opening the Marina Aquatic and Sports Center.

Does that alone establish that Measure Q is unnecessary?

No. The useful comparison is the documented General Fund day-to-day effect of the recreation facility versus the separate project need for Police, Fire and City Hall. The two should not be combined without showing the accounting connection.

Preston Park

Are funding, Habitat Management Plan, grants, scope and transfers legitimate questions?

Yes. They should be answered from the Preston Park project record and fund accounting.

Should every Preston Park balance be counted as cash available for the Measure Q facilities?

Not automatically. A balance, refunding capacity, transfer or appropriation is not necessarily unrestricted General Fund cash. The relevant questions are the source, legal restrictions, commitments and amount actually transferable.

Fund-by-fund discussion →

Sea Haven Park and City Park at The Dunes

Do schedules and delays matter?

Yes. They help evaluate whether the City and developers are meeting commitments.

Are these the same funding question as Measure Q?

Usually not. Development parks can involve development agreements, developer obligations, impact fees, grants and restricted project sources. A delayed park can be a project-management concern without proving that its money could legally be moved to Police, Fire or City Hall.

Development use cases →

Citizen concern: Sea Haven Park priorities

A resident asked why Marina is moving forward with Sea Haven Community Park while also discussing Fire, Police and other facility needs. This is a reasonable priorities question, but the funding record matters.

Is Sea Haven Park a Measure Q project?

No. The current park project was planned and funded before Measure Q. In April 2026, the City approved a construction contract and estimated total completion costs of about $5.03 million, including construction, contingency, permits and project administration.

Is the park connected to Sea Haven development fees?

Yes. City records identify a $1.953 million Sea Haven developer park fee and a prior $1.8 million Public Facility Impact Fee allocation. The City says these impact fees are charged with new residential building permits to provide parks needed because of growth.

Why is the City building the park?

The developer was originally responsible for construction. In 2025, after costs exceeded the developer's established budget, the City amended the development agreement, took responsibility for construction and arranged for the Sea Haven park fee to be paid directly to the City.

What this does and does not answer: Residents can disagree about priorities. However, the available record does not support describing Sea Haven Park as a Measure Q project or as a $20 million park. A concern about the park does not itself answer whether Measure Q is the right approach for public-safety facilities.

For the current project balance or an official explanation of funding, contact the City Manager's Office or request City Resolutions 2025-11 and 2026-35 from the City Clerk.

Community Feedback and Questions

Recurring public questions, the supporting record, and links to concise responses.

Public-question index

Read concise summaries of recurring public questions and their source-based answers →

Public Comment 005: Could existing City money build Police and Fire facilities now?

Issue raised: A September 16, 2026 online post argues that Marina missed three opportunities to use General Fund money, impact fees, cash and investments, and other resources to build public-safety facilities before asking voters to consider Measure Q. This is a valid Measure Q question. The answer depends on whether each cited balance was unrestricted, legally usable for facilities, still available after commitments, and enough to complete the projects.

Point raisedWhat the record supports
Measure U should not be left out.Correct. In 2024, voters considered a $50 million general-obligation bond for facilities. About 60% voted yes, but two-thirds approval was required. Voters had an opportunity to choose property-tax bond financing and did not approve it. The City then moved to other funding approaches, including the current UUT proposal.
Unassigned General Fund money and impact fees could have paid for Police and Fire buildings.Partly true, but incomplete. A Council can choose to use unassigned General Fund balance for one-time capital needs. That decision also uses resources that can support reserves, future obligations, or other City needs. Impact fees may fund only the growth-related share of a facility. They cannot automatically fund the full cost of a station serving the whole community.
The City did not use earlier funding for facilities.Not supported by the current City materials. The City says it has already secured about $19.3 million from grants, impact fees and other sources toward three facilities now estimated at about $69.3 million. Residents can question the pace and choices, but those sources were not simply omitted from the facilities analysis.
Preston Park money assigned to facilities was redirected to Dunes Park.Inaccurate as stated. October 2025 minutes record $6.5 million for a Preston Park loan paydown and about $6 million for later project decisions. The later May 2026 adjustments identified $4.4 million for Dunes Park and $2.1 million for the Public Facility Building Fund. That is not a single $6.5 million facilities allocation transferred to Dunes Park.
The March 31, 2026 cash-and-investments report proves the City has $195.94 million available for facilities.The total is correct; the availability conclusion is not established. Table I reports $195.94 million in aggregate cash and investments. It separately lists $171.32 million in the City category, $11.06 million in fiduciary funds, $10.31 million for Preston, and $3.25 million for Abrams. The table is an investment and liquidity summary. It does not identify the unrestricted General Fund amount, legal restrictions, appropriations, reserves, contract commitments or money held for other entities.
Aquatic Center financing, Cal Am litigation, sidewalks, and park spending should be considered.Yes. They are legitimate budget-priority questions. Each has a separate funding source, purpose, Council action, and possible restriction. The post does not provide the fund-by-fund accounting needed to show that these amounts could instead be used for public-safety construction.

Related question: Would paying cash avoid nearly $50 million in bond interest?

Yes, if the City had $50 million of unrestricted cash available for the facilities. Borrowing $50 million over 30 years costs more than paying $50 million in cash. At a fixed 5.25% interest rate, the annual payment would be about $3.31 million and total principal and interest would be about $99.4 million, before issuance costs. Calling that “about double” is a reasonable rough estimate at that interest rate.

But the comparison assumes the City has $50 million that it can legally and prudently spend at once. The public record reviewed for this site does not establish that. The City’s cash-and-investments report includes restricted, fiduciary, Preston, Abrams, reserve, committed, and City accounts. Those balances cannot automatically be combined and treated as facilities cash.

The City currently estimates about $69.3 million for the three facilities and about a $50 million gap after identified funding sources. Measure Q itself does not require a bond. It is a General Fund revenue measure. A future Council could consider borrowing, phased cash construction, reserves, grants, or a combination. The practical question is whether enough unrestricted cash exists to avoid borrowing without reducing reserves, violating funding restrictions, or cutting other services.

What the March 31 cash report proves, and what it does not

Reported categoryMarch 31, 2026 amountWhat this table can establish
City$171.32MCash and investments reported under the City category, including a $4.40M line expressly labeled restricted money market: bond proceeds/reserves.
Fiduciary$11.06MA separately reported fiduciary category, including a $6.08M line expressly labeled restricted money market: bond proceeds/reserves.
Preston$10.31MA separately reported Preston balance, not shown in the table as a General Fund balance.
Abrams$3.25MA separately reported Abrams balance, not shown in the table as a General Fund balance.
Total cash and investments$195.94MThe four reported subtotals add to the stated total.

Certification of the narrow factual point: The March 31 report supports the $195.94 million total and the four subtotals shown above. It does not certify that $195.94 million, or even the $171.32 million City subtotal, was unassigned, legally transferable or prudent to spend on facilities. The earlier claim that the report was merely a vague $174 million figure was incomplete and is corrected here.

What remains unanswered? The public record should be used to confirm the unrestricted General Fund balance after commitments, the City Council's current appropriations from the City category, the current Aquatic Center loan balance, and the source and remaining amounts of the Cal Am and sidewalk appropriations. Those are appropriate questions for the City Finance Department and City Clerk.

Bottom line: A phased construction plan, a smaller future tax, greater use of reserves, and additional grants are all reasonable alternatives for voters to weigh. However, the figures in the post do not by themselves prove that Marina had enough legally available money to build one or two complete public-safety facilities without a new revenue source. They also do not prove that the City acted irresponsibly.

Read the records: Measure U and facilities history · fund-by-fund context · budget questions · Measure Q overview · City Council agenda packets and minutes.

Public Comment 006: Did the Imjin Parkway project show City project-management failure?

Issue raised: A resident asked why Marina takes on projects if it cannot deliver them on time or within budget, and described the Imjin Parkway roundabout project as a failure that cost residents money. This is a reasonable question about project delivery. The public record supports a more specific conclusion.

QuestionWhat the published record shows
Did Marina take over a troubled project from TAMC?That description is not verified. TAMC's 2023 announcement identifies the City of Marina as the project lead. The published materials describe a City-TAMC partnership, not a documented transfer of a failing TAMC project to the City.
What was the project?A regional corridor improvement. The project widened about 1.7 miles of Imjin Parkway, added four roundabouts, bike and pedestrian improvements, lighting, stormwater work and landscaping.
Who paid for it?It was not presented as a General Fund-only project. The project site identifies development impact fees, Measure X and the State's Local Partnership Program as funding sources. In April 2025, the City's capital-improvement program listed the project at $43.9 million, fully funded, with no additional funding need shown.
Was construction completed on time?The published construction schedule supports an early completion of the listed phases. The project site had anticipated completion around June 2026. It lists the fourth and final construction phase as completed December 30, 2025, and states that all lanes and roundabouts were open February 27, 2026.
Was it completed on budget?Not yet proven by a final public closeout record. The April 2025 capital-improvement program showed a fully funded budget. That is not the same as a final contract closeout, final cost report or independent audit. Those records should be requested before anyone claims final under-budget or on-budget completion.

What this does and does not show

The available evidence does not support calling Imjin Parkway a project-management failure. It shows Marina leading a complex, externally funded regional project that opened its road network before the project site's anticipated June 2026 completion date. Residents may still question traffic effects, design choices or long-term maintenance, but those are different questions from whether the construction project failed.

Imjin is also a useful, but limited, precedent for Sea Haven Community Park. In both cases, the City is managing a public project with restricted or project-specific funding and outside partners. Imjin does not prove that Sea Haven will have the same outcome because the scope, contract history and risks are different. For Sea Haven, City records say the developer's construction budget was exceeded, after which the City took responsibility for construction and arranged for the developer park fee to be paid directly to the City.

What still needs City confirmation: the final contract amount, all change orders, final acceptance date, final total project cost and any remaining grant or maintenance obligations. These are appropriate records to request from the City Clerk or City Public Works Department.

Read the records: Imjin Parkway project phases, scope and funding · TAMC announcement identifying Marina as lead agency · City FY 2025-27 capital-improvement program · Sea Haven Park funding record · City Council agenda packets and minutes.

Public Comment 007: Can future Councils spend Measure Q revenue on different priorities, and can the tax be ended?

Issue raised: A recurring online comment says that Measure Q is a general-fund tax, so a current or future Council may choose how to spend the money, and that the tax would be difficult to end. This question is directly relevant to Measure Q. It was not the subject of Public Comments 001 through 004, although the same general-tax distinction appears elsewhere on this site.

StatementWhat the proposed ordinance says
Measure Q revenue would not be legally reserved only for Police, Fire and City Hall.Correct. Section 2 says the revenue is for unrestricted general revenue purposes and does not bind the City to a specific purpose or function. The facilities are a stated reason for the measure, not an exclusive legal restriction.
A future Council could set different spending priorities.Correct, within the law. General Fund spending is decided through the City budget. A later Council can make different annual budget choices, subject to applicable law, contracts, debt obligations and the measure's local-use, disclosure and audit provisions.
The money could be spent on anything a Council chooses.Too broad. The revenue is unrestricted for general City purposes, not for private, unlawful or non-City purposes. The ordinance requires local spending, annual independent audit and public reporting of the annual revenue and its use.
The tax could only be ended by voters and would therefore be difficult to end.Incomplete. The ballot language and termination section say the tax continues until ended by voters. However, Section 3.07.270 also expressly allows the City Council to repeal or amend the chapter without a vote of the people. Voter approval would be required for an amendment that increases the tax rate.

What voters should take from this

The post correctly identifies the main tradeoff. Measure Q is not a facilities-only tax, and future Councils would retain annual budget discretion. It is reasonable for a voter to prefer a tax with a binding project list, a separate account or a fixed end date. Those features were not included in Measure Q.

At the same time, the proposed ordinance does not make the tax impossible to end. It expressly permits Council repeal or amendment, while preserving voter approval for a rate increase. The ballot language also tells voters that the tax continues until ended by voters. The City Clerk and City Attorney are the appropriate sources for a definitive legal interpretation of any future Council action.

Read the records: Measure Q overview and claim comparison · general-tax safeguards and funding context · full ballot resolution and proposed ordinance · City Council agenda packets and minutes.

Public Comment 009: “The City has done nothing with the revenues collected over the years.”

Issue raised: A resident asked why the public should trust the City now if it has done nothing with revenue collected over the years to address the facility problem. The concern about past priorities is legitimate. The word “nothing”, however, is not supported by the City records reviewed here.

QuestionWhat the record supports
Does City revenue only sit unused until a capital project is chosen?No. The City describes its General Fund as supporting day-to-day police, fire, public works, recreation, planning and administration. Its published FY 2025–26 General Fund budget is $38.5 million; the City says these revenues maintain current services but are not designed to fully fund very large one-time facility replacements.
Has the City completed no capital work?No. A 2025 City staff report identifies Glorya Jean Tate Improvements Phase 1, two large blight-removal projects, and Preston Park Improvements Phase 1 as completed under the City’s capital-program management partnership. Separately, the City’s Imjin Parkway project record says the final construction phase was completed December 30, 2025 and all lanes and roundabouts opened February 27, 2026.
Does this show that every earlier priority was correct or that the facilities should not have been funded sooner?No. A completed-project list cannot answer whether a different Council priority would have been better. That remains a fair voter judgment. It also does not identify every project’s funding source or prove that each project used unrestricted General Fund money.
Does this record turn Measure Q into a binding facilities fund?No. Measure Q is a general tax. The City says it would go to the General Fund, and the proposed ordinance does not reserve it only for the three facilities. Voters can reasonably decide that the City’s past choices or the measure’s flexibility weigh for or against approval.

Documented completed City projects, September 2016–September 2026

This is a documented list, not an exhaustive ten-year audit. It includes projects the cited City records expressly describe as completed during the period or as completed under the 2020–2025 capital-program partnership. The City has not published a single, consolidated ten-year completion ledger in the materials reviewed for this entry.

ProjectCompletion recordWhat this list does not establish
Glorya Jean Tate Improvements — Phase 1Listed by City staff in May 2025 as a completed project under the capital-program management partnership.Project cost, funding source and any remaining maintenance obligation require the underlying project file.
Two large blight-removal projectsListed by City staff in May 2025 as completed projects under the same partnership.The staff report identifies two projects but does not name them in the excerpt; the project files are needed for a project-by-project accounting.
Preston Park Improvements — Phase 1Listed by City staff in May 2025 as a completed project under the same partnership.This does not resolve separate questions about Preston Park financing or future phases.
Imjin Parkway widening and roundaboutsThe project record states that Phase 4 was completed December 30, 2025 and all lanes and roundabouts opened February 27, 2026.Opening is not a final audited cost closeout; final costs and change orders should still be confirmed.

Bottom line: The documented record does not support saying the City did nothing. It does support asking whether past operating and capital choices, including the pace of facilities planning, were the best choices. For Measure Q, the separate decision is whether a general-tax funding source—with local-use, disclosure and audit provisions but no facilities-only legal restriction—is acceptable to the voter.

Read the records: City Facilities and Budget · City Measure Q page · May 2025 capital-program management staff report · Imjin Parkway project record · Measure Q overview · source index for this entry.

Public Comment 010: What’s in a name? Does Measure Q’s ballot title fairly describe the measure?

Issue raised: A recurring public comment questions whether the title “Marina 911 Emergency, Public Safety, and Community Services Measure” gives too much emphasis to City services and should instead be titled “7% Utility Users Tax.” This matters because California election law requires impartial ballot language.

QuestionWhat the record supports
Does California law require impartial ballot language?Yes. Elections Code section 13119(c) requires a true and impartial synopsis that is neither argumentative nor likely to create prejudice for or against a measure. For a tax measure, section 13119(b) also requires the ballot statement to include the annual amount to be raised, the tax rate, and the duration.
Does the official Measure Q question disclose that it is a tax?Yes. The question proposes a 7% utility users’ tax, estimates about $3.83 million annually, states a low-income rate, says the tax continues until ended by voters, and identifies disclosure, audit, and local-use provisions.
Does the title itself create a legal spending restriction?No. Measure Q is a general tax. The listed services and projects are stated purposes, but the revenue is not legally reserved only for those purposes.
Does use of a public-safety title alone establish a legal violation?No court ruling has been identified. A voter may reasonably prefer a more tax-focused title. Under the cases summarized below, courts look for wording that is accurate and impartial, rather than the one phrasing that every voter would choose. No ruling has been located finding Marina’s title unlawful.

California court examples on ballot wording

The following six examples provide context. They do not decide Measure Q, and some involve statewide or school-district measures rather than a City general tax.

CaseOutcomeWhat it shows
Martinez v. Superior Court (2006)City wording upheldA ballot title need not use the challenger’s preferred words if it is not false, misleading, or partial.
Yes on 25 v. Superior Court (2010)State wording upheldCourts generally give latitude to wording that closely follows the measure and accurately explains its effect.
Becerra v. Superior Court (2018)State wording upheldA court does not rewrite wording simply because another order or emphasis might also be reasonable. The title and summary are read together.
McDonough v. Superior Court (2012)Court required wording changesCourts can require revisions when ballot wording is found to be argumentative or prejudicial.
Osborne v. Logan (2026)Tax-disclosure rule identifiedFor a bond measure, the tax rate on the ballot had to be stated consistently with the required tax-rate statement. This concerns financial disclosure, not a descriptive title.
Holtz v. Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors (2026)Trial court modified materials; appellate court did not decide the wording issueA recent local-tax example, but not a controlling appellate ruling on ballot-title language.

Summary: Other California cases generally follow the same pattern. Courts look for a true, impartial description that is not argumentative, prejudicial, or likely to mislead. They usually uphold reasonable wording that states a measure’s main purpose and effects. Courts are more likely to intervene when required financial information is missing, a material effect is obscured, or wording functions as advocacy rather than description.

Read the records: California Elections Code section 13119 · City Measure Q page and official ballot wording · Measure Q overview · general-tax safeguards and funding context · source index for this entry.

Public Comment 011: Would Measure Q tax government charges already on a utility bill?

Issue raised: A resident asked whether the 7% Utility Users Tax would apply to state, federal, or other government charges that already appear on a utility bill.

Answer: Yes, in many cases. Measure Q would be calculated on the utility charges shown on a bill, including many government-required fees and surcharges. If a utility bill includes a state, federal, regulatory, or water-district charge, that amount can be included before the 7% UUT is calculated.

Put simply: a customer may pay the UUT on part of a bill that already includes other government charges. People often call that a “tax on a tax.” The ordinance uses the more specific terms fees, charges, and surcharges.

This does not mean every unrelated tax or household expense is taxed. It applies only to charges connected to covered water, electricity, gas, phone, and video services. The exact treatment of a particular line item will depend on how the utility provider bills it. The City should publish sample bills or provider guidance before collection begins so residents can see which line items are included.

Read the records: Resolution 2026-100 and proposed Utility Users’ Tax ordinance · City Measure Q page · source index for this entry.

Public Comment 012: Does Measure Q give large businesses a special rebate or let the Council exempt anyone?

Issue raised: An October 2026 public post asks why Measure Q includes a rebate for some business utility users and gives the City Council power to create exemptions. It is a direct Measure Q question. It concerns the proposed tax rate, who pays it, and future Council power.

QuestionWhat the proposed ordinance says
Does Measure Q include a business rebate?Yes. Section 3.07.090 applies to commercial gas and electricity users, but not to gas and electric utilities. It requires a monthly rebate of tax paid above an annual amount set by the City Council.
Is $9,900 the most a business could receive as a rebate?No. The $9,900 figure is the highest initial annual tax amount the Council may set before a rebate begins. The Council may set a lower amount. The ordinance does not limit the dollar value of the rebate itself.
Does the rebate cover all utility taxes?No. The provision covers only the combined gas and electricity UUT. It does not cover water, phone, or video-service UUT.
Does the City forecast millions of dollars in annual business rebates?Not in the published material reviewed. The City’s June study estimated about $12.57 million in total annual commercial gas and electricity charges. At 7%, that equals about $880,000 in tax before rebates for all commercial users combined. The City did not publish a rebate forecast or name businesses that might qualify.
Can the Council exempt anyone or any business from the tax?Not as written. The Council may adopt a public resolution to exempt a defined group of people or utility services, in whole or in part, for a specified period. The ordinance does not name a business or give a permanent individual exemption.

Who might reach the rebate threshold?

The Council has not set the threshold. The ordinance allows a threshold no higher than $9,900 in annual combined electricity-and-gas UUT, adjusted for inflation. At the proposed 7% rate, that maximum threshold equals about $141,400 a year, or $11,800 a month, in combined electricity and gas charges before a rebate would begin. If the Council chooses a lower threshold, the required utility spending would also be lower.

For example, at the maximum permitted threshold, a service user with $150,000 in annual eligible charges would initially owe $10,500 in UUT and receive a $600 rebate. A service user with $250,000 in eligible charges would initially owe $17,500 and receive a $7,600 rebate. These examples address only the gas-and-electricity provision, not water, phone, or video-service UUT.

The City has not released account-level utility data, so no one can responsibly identify a qualifying business. A review of current and publicly planned Marina development suggests that perhaps six to ten large facilities could plausibly be close enough to merit review, including high-use hotels, big-box or grocery retail, aviation or manufacturing uses, medical-office complexes, and master-metered commercial centers. That is a planning estimate, not a list of beneficiaries. Whether any site qualifies depends on actual bills, separate meters, and the identity of the billed service user.

Is this unusual?

No, but it is not standard. Some California cities place annual limits on utility-user taxes for large or high-use service users. Modesto, for example, has a $1,500 annual maximum for each separately metered utility service, while Alhambra has a $70,000 annual maximum for a commercial or industrial plant location. Other cities, including Santa Barbara and Rialto, publish UUTs that apply to commercial users without identifying a high-use commercial cap in their public materials. Marina’s proposed approach is a narrower rebate for nonresidential electricity and gas, rather than a full exemption from all UUT.

What is established, and what is not

The Council approved the full proposed ordinance when it placed Measure Q on the ballot. That establishes that the rebate and class-exemption provisions are part of the proposal. The written staff report explains the low-income and senior reductions, but the documents reviewed do not explain why the separate business rebate was included.

The question of fairness is an open policy judgment. The proposed ordinance gives the Council future power, but it does not name who would receive rebates or show a projected total cost. If voters want a reason for the business rebate, the threshold the Council would use, or an estimate of likely revenue effects, the City Council or City Manager’s Office should provide that explanation.

Read the records: proposed Measure Q ordinance · City/Keyser Marston utility study · City of Modesto UUT · Alhambra commercial/industrial UUT maximum · source index for this entry.

Public Comment 013: Do past Marina tax measures show that Measure Q's public-safety wording is only a promise?

Issue raised: A repeated public post compares ballot language from Marina measures approved in 2010, 2016, and 2018 with the failed 2024 Measure U and proposed 2026 Measure Q. It asks why earlier tax revenue was not used for fire and police buildings.

Short answer: The comparison is useful, but the measures had different legal rules. The earlier sales, hotel, and business taxes sent money to the General Fund. Their ballot text named City services, but did not set aside money for a new station. The 2024 Measure U was a property-tax bond for facilities. It got 60% support, short of the two-thirds needed. Measure Q is a proposed utility tax, not a bond.

Measure or groupWhat it didWhy the legal difference matters
2010 Measures M and NTemporarily raised local sales and hotel taxes for City services. Both ballot questions named fire, police, streets, parks, and other services.The text listed broad priorities. It did not set aside money for a fire or police building.
2016 Measure UChanged the business tax to a gross-receipts tax. The ballot question named City services, including fire, police, streets, and facilities.It added General Fund revenue. It was not a voter-approved building fund.
2018 Measures N and PRaised local sales and hotel taxes. City election records say the added revenue went to the General Fund.The annual City budget, not the ballot summary, decided how the money was used.
2024 Measure UWould have authorized $50 million in bonds for facility projects, including fire, police, and City facilities.It was a property-tax bond with a project purpose. It needed two-thirds approval and failed with 60% support.
2026 Measure QWould create a 7% Utility Users Tax. The proposed ordinance puts the money in the General Fund.Its public-safety and facility language names purposes. It does not reserve money only for those purposes.

What the records show, and what they do not show

Public safety has been paid for through the General Fund. The City’s audited 2023-24 report lists $13.35 million in General Fund public-safety spending. A sales, hotel, or business-tax dollar cannot be matched to one service or project. General Fund money is pooled, and the City Council adopts the annual budget.

The history does not prove that public-safety language was a ruse. It also does not prove that past City choices were the best choices. It does show that general-tax ballot questions often name public safety and other services. Residents can reasonably ask for answers about that history. They should also tell apart a general tax and a bond or building fund before deciding what a ballot question legally promises.

What remains unanswered: Ballot text alone cannot show whether the City could have paid for every facility project earlier. That would require yearly data on General Fund revenue, service costs, reserves, grants, debt, project costs, and Council budgets. The published records provide part of that history. They do not assign every tax dollar to every project.

Read the records: 2010 County election results · 2016 County election results · 2018 election certification · City Measure Q page · source index for this entry.

Equestrian Center

Does an RFP or concessionaire decision affect Measure Q?

Not directly on the information presently documented. RFP transparency and concession terms are legitimate oversight questions. They become relevant to Measure Q if a documented General Fund cost, money raised commitment or transferable resource materially changes the building funding assumptions.

Cal Am desalination litigation

Is total litigation spending a legitimate question?

Yes. Residents can ask for total legal cost, current appropriation, funding source and remaining exposure. The City continues to state that it is involved in litigation over the proposed desalination project and identifies groundwater and environmental concerns as the basis for its position.

Does disagreement over the litigation settle the Measure Q question?

No. It can affect views of City priorities, but the financial question is narrower: how much unrestricted General Fund capacity would exist without that expense, and would it materially change the facilities funding gap?

Del Monte Boulevard, Reservation Road and the roundabout

Why have previously budgeted transportation projects not been completed?

That is a legitimate project-delivery question. Before treating an appropriation as money available for another purpose, identify whether it is a grant, impact fee, transportation money raised, local match or unrestricted General Fund appropriation.

Could Measure Q money raised be used for roads?

Yes. The official ballot language expressly includes streets and potholes and permits general City services. Existing transportation-project funds still need to be analyzed separately.

Reservation Road signals and corridor improvements

An appropriation means money was authorized for a purpose. It does not by itself establish that the money is unrestricted, unencumbered or available for public-safety facilities. The useful questions are funding source, remaining balance, restrictions, grant or contract deadlines, and whether Council could legally move it.

Development incentives and “giveaways”

Should development incentives be considered when judging City finances?

Yes, project by project. Test the public cost against the expected money raised or benefit. Some arrangements involve future tax sharing, land agreements, infrastructure obligations or development-specific money raised rather than an immediate unrestricted cash payment.

When does one become relevant to Measure Q?

When a documented agreement creates a General Fund obligation or foregone money raised large enough to materially change the claimed building funding gap. Otherwise it remains an important development-policy question, but a separate one.

Development agreements and ROI →

Should Measure Q have a resident oversight committee?

The current Measure Q materials require annual independent audits and public spending disclosure, and the City describes community oversight. Earlier facilities-bond materials contemplated an independent citizens' oversight committee for bond spendings.

A Measure Q oversight body could meet periodically with the City Manager, Finance staff and project staff, review money raised, spendings, facility schedules and major variances, then publish a short public report. Because Measure Q is a general tax, its authority would need to match the law and Council action.

Important distinction: an independent audit tests financial reporting and compliance. A resident committee can add transparency and public review, but it does not convert a general tax into a restricted by law facilities tax.

When the same claim keeps returning

Some public arguments are not single factual questions. They combine a real City decision, an incomplete fact, a later outcome and a broader conclusion such as “the City always gives developers money” or “there is plenty of cash, so Measure Q is unnecessary.” Repetition does not make the conclusion more complete.

How this site handles that type of claim

First, preserve the legitimate question. If a resident identifies a real contract, spending, delay or inconsistency, it belongs in the record.

Second, restore the decision-time context. A 2005 or 2008 development agreement should be evaluated using the agreement, market conditions, land value, infrastructure obligations and negotiated terms that existed then. A later home sale price or later development value does not retroactively rewrite the contract.

Third, separate error from consequence. A mistaken statement by a Council member, staff member or critic may deserve correction. The next question is whether the error changed a vote, contract, legal obligation, project cost or Measure Q loan assumption.

Fourth, stop the issue from swallowing the ballot question. Once the documented connection to Measure Q has been identified, the page links to the detailed issue and returns to the tax, facilities need, available money and funding choices.

Editorial rule: This site does not try to win an endless argument with one resident or one social-media thread. It documents the strongest version of a claim, checks it against primary records, identifies what is correct or missing, and tells the reader whether the result materially changes Measure Q.

Old decisions, current prices and hindsight

Marina's development history spans decades. A common source of confusion is comparing today's property value, tax money raised or construction cost with an agreement negotiated many years earlier. The relevant baseline is normally the contract and economic setting when the obligation was created, unless the agreement itself requires later revaluation or renegotiation.

This matters for development fees, land transactions, infrastructure commitments and money raised-sharing agreements. A claim can accurately state today's value and still reach an unsupported conclusion if it omits the contractual valuation date or the consideration Marina received in return.

See the development agreements and decision-time analysis →

Public-record requests and transparency disputes

Public records are an important way to test City claims. Marina provides a California Public Records Act request process through the City Clerk, and Police records use a separate records process. A records dispute, copying charge or slow response can be a legitimate transparency concern.

But the Measure Q test remains the same: What did the resulting record establish? A dispute over obtaining a document does not by itself prove that the actual spending, contract or ballot assumption is wrong. When a record changes the financial analysis, this site should update the relevant page and source table.

What should a reader do with a long list of unrelated City complaints?

Do not accept or reject the list as a package. Break it apart. Some items may be correct, some may be incomplete, and some may have little financial relationship to Measure Q. Use the relevance guide above, then follow only the issues that materially affect the ballot decision.

Five questions to use when a new claim appears

1. What fund is the money in? General Fund, grant, impact fee, developer obligation, enterprise/rental money raised, transportation fund, future tax sharing or debt?

2. Can it legally be moved? A large balance is not automatically available for another project.

3. How large is it? If available, would it materially change the approximately $69.3 million facilities need or the proposed funding?

4. Is this a oversight concern or a funding fact? Both can matter, but they answer different questions.

5. Is there a documented connection? If there is, follow it. If there is not, keep the issue visible but separate rather than using it as a substitute for the Measure Q financial analysis.